Anne Hathaway, having starred in numerous romantic comedies, has undoubtedly become an expert in the genre. Thus, when the queen of Genovia was asked about her favorite rom-com during an appearance on the James Corden show, her response left the audience in shock, to say the least.

Now, whether she was joking or serious remains a topic of debate, but her choice can be perceived as either daringly unconventional or the insight of a true connoisseur, understood only by someone of her expertise.

What is Anne Hathaway’s Favorite Rom-Com?

Anne Hathaway undeniably holds a special place in the hearts of internet users worldwide. Her captivating presence and iconic beauty are qualities many admire. Having established herself as a rom-com icon, the actress in the resurfaced clip divulged her top picks for favorite romantic comedies, and they are certainly unconventional choices.

Anne Hathaway stands among the select few who truly understand their craft. Thus, during her visit to the James Corden show, The Late Show with James Corden, she shared her top two selections. While Notting Hill was a somewhat expected choice, another was not so much.

Another choice was Gone Girl, and Hathaway had her reasons to advocate for it, she explained (via Vulture),

“I have two. It’s Notting Hill, yeah it’s a classi–And more recently, Gone Girl.Think about it. It’s like a David Fincher rom-com!”

As soon as she revealed her choice of Gone Girl, the entire crowd fell silent for obvious reasons, causing some to question whether they should cheer as enthusiastically as they did for Notting Hill, given her reasons.

happy valentine’s day to anne hathaway gagging the audience with her favorite rom com pic.twitter.com/vWF6kTXpEP

— popculture (@notgwendalupe) February 14, 2024

But hey, Anne Hathaway is one of the few who knows exactly what she’s doing, and there’s no questioning her judgment. While Gone Girl may not be a traditional choice, Hathaway’s endorsement suggests it could be David Fincher’s unexpected love story, since the director s𝓀𝒾𝓁𝓁fully blends thriller and rom-com elements, ultimately gifting the audiences the ultimate love story.

Do Fans Agree with Anne Hathaway’s Statement?

When it comes to romcoms, it takes a s𝓀𝒾𝓁𝓁ful eye to detect the elements that truly make up a compelling love story. The picks many might have expected often don’t fit into the perfect cookie-cutter vision of the genre. Thus, when the actress shared her picks, while many were baffled, others immediately understood where she was coming from.