Nicole made headlines when she showcased her stunning engagement ring—a remarkable 4-carat diamond with an 18-karat yellow gold inlay—while attending the Venice Film Festival premiere of “Beetlejuice” alongside Theroux. In a candid interview with the Times shortly after, Theroux shared his emotions leading up to the proposal, admitting, “Of course I was nervous proposing; it is a question, after all, so the answer isn’t guaranteed. But it was wonderful.”